21
Sat, Dec
127 New Articles

Trademark Triumph: Landmark Profit Surrender Ruling In Serbia

Trademark Triumph: Landmark Profit Surrender Ruling In Serbia

Serbia
Tools
Typography
  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

Serbia’s 2020 Trademark Law introduced a novel provision to local law: the trademark holders have been explicitly empowered to claim profit surrender in cases where the infringement was not intentional or grossly negligent.

Specifically, the Law stipulates:  If the violation of rights was not committed intentionally or through gross negligence, the court may award the plaintiff compensation in the amount of the profit that the defendant gained through the violation of rights. This provision not only limits the liability of defendants in such cases, but also significantly eases the burden of proof for a trademark holder seeking to be awarded for trademark infringement.

In one of the first court rulings relying on this legal ground and this specific provision, the court awarded the trademark holder with over EUR 1.2 million profit calculated from the sale of products bearing the disputed mark. The legal battle in the first instance focused on several contentious and complex legal issues:

  • Does the trademark holder have to prove that they suffered damage to claim profit surrender?
  • Does the trademark holder have to prove the contribution of the use of the trademark to the profit obtained?
  • Can trademark holders seek profit surrender for infringements that had occurred before enactment of the novel of the Trademark Law in 2020?

The first instance ruling answers these questions, allowing straightforward monetary award based on the established trademark infringement without the trademark holder having to prove additional facts. It remains to be seen whether higher court instances will uphold this interpretation, which would significantly enhance the position of rights holders and improve the efficiency of the existing protection system.

This landmark case not only underscores the importance of robust legal representation but also highlights the evolving landscape of intellectual property rights in Serbia. Whether you’re an IP enthusiast or a stakeholder in the industry, this decision is a game-changer worth noting. Stay tuned to see how this story unfolds in the higher courts!

* ZMP represents the plaintiff in this court dispute. All standpoints and insights referenced in this article represent personal opinions and professional views of the author.

This text is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice. Should you require any additional information, feel free to contact us.

By Mina Jovanovic Ninkovic, Senior Counsel, ZMP

ZMP at a Glance

Established in 1939 in Belgrade, Serbia, ZMP (Živko Mijatović & Partners) has become one of the most prominent IP law firms in Central and Eastern Europe. For more than 80 years, ZMP has been advising
and representing clients in the areas of intellectual property ranging from patent strategy and IP litigation to copyright, design, trademark, trade secrets, and unfair competition law. The firm also handles prosecution and enforcement matters, both for international and local clients.

In addition, ZMP is in a unique position to manage multi-jurisdictional anti-counterfeiting programs, which is one of the firm's strongest points. It handles these programs for some of the biggest brand owners in the world who are anxious to stop counterfeit products coming from Turkey, the Middle East, and China before they enter the EU.

Many of ZMP’s clients are leaders in their industries, such as pharmaceuticals, chemicals, computer science, entertainment, telecommunications, food and beverages, fashion, etc. Clients benefit from the firm’s strategically focused approach to the creation and protection of their brands and content. It understands their concerns and offers tailor-made and cost-efficient solutions.

To provide comprehensive services to regional and international clients with business interests in multiple jurisdictions, the firm has grown to 15 offices throughout Southeastern Europe over time, with its HQ in Belgrade and its Client Service Office in Alicante, Spain, acting as hubs around which all other offices operate. The streamlined flow of information between offices is accomplished through cloud-based file sharing and a consolidated back office. Clients can receive tailor-made services consistently across all ZMP offices through only one point of contact if desired.

ZMP’s network covers the protection of European Trademarks (EUTM) and provides full IP services in 15 countries, namely: Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Hungary, Kosovo, North Macedonia, Montenegro, Poland, Romania, Serbia, Slovak Republic, Slovenia, and Spain.

One point of contact, the flawless and constant level of service throughout all offices, in-depth knowledge of local and regional legal frameworks, markets, politics, and culture, and seasoned professionals with years of extensive experience are what make ZMP stand out.

Firm's website: ZMP