17
Thu, Jun
57 New Articles

Squire Patton Boggs Successful for Turkmenistan in ICSID Arbitration Against Turkish Claimants

Squire Patton Boggs Successful for Turkmenistan in ICSID Arbitration Against Turkish Claimants

Turkey
Tools
Typography
  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

Squire Patton Boggs, acting on behalf of the State of Turkmenistan, has persuaded the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes to dismiss in full a claim of nearly USD 500 million brought against the country by Turkish construction company Sehil Insaat Endustri ve Ticaret Ltd. Sti. and its majority shareholder Muhammet Cap.

The case, Muhammet Cap and Sehil v. Turkmenistan, was registered in 2012 under the Turkey-Turkmenistan bilateral investment treaty. The dispute concerned 32 construction projects in Turkmenistan, including water and waste treatment plants, an iron and steel plant, schools and government buildings. The claimants alleged that they had been impeded by delays and defaults by their contractual counter-parties and by regulatory procedures, that they were entitled to additional compensation for work outside the scope of the contracts, and that they were unfairly subject to delay penalties, tax audits, and court orders terminating the contracts. Their contractual counter-parties argued that terminations and penalties were justified due to Sehil’s failure to perform its contractual obligations, defective work, and non-completion.

According to Squire Patton Boggs, "the tribunal rejected all claims against Turkmenistan and held that Sehil’s contractual counter-parties acted in the legitimate exercise of their contractual rights and in a commercial capacity, and that the Turkmenistan courts, tax authorities, and prosecutors acted in accordance with Turkmenistan law and procedures and did not violate due process. 

The Squire Patton Boggs team representing Turkmenistan was led by New York Partners Ali Gursel, Miriam Harwood, and Zeynep Gunday Sakarya, and included Counsel Bahar Charyyeva, Associate Carlos Guzman, and Paralegal Hesel Toyjanova.

According to Gursel, “this case was complex not only due to the fact that it involved 32 different construction projects – each of which could have been a free-standing arbitration in its own right – but also due to the intervening bankruptcy of the claimant company in Turkey while the arbitration was in progress.”

The claimants were represented by, among others, the Derains & Gharavi, Offit Kurman, and Egemenoglu Law Firms.

Turkey Knowledge Partner

NAZALI offers a broad range of services in the fields of Tax, Audit, Corporate and Commercial Law, Mergers & Acquisitions, Corporate Finance, Banking, Finance and Capital Markets, Protective Legal Services and Dispute Resolution, Personal Data Protection and Privacy, Social Security and Labor Law, Occupational Health and Safety, Competition Law, Intellectual Property Law and R&D, Compliance and White-Collar Crimes, Administrative Law, Real Estate Law, Customs and Foreign Trade, Accounting and Payroll, Financial Incentives and Advisory Services and Public Administration and Compliance through its partners, associates and consultants of different seniorities who have both public and private sector experience.

What sets NAZALI apart from others is that NAZALI offers a truly comprehensive service to its clients with experts from different disciplines working collaboratively as a team under one roof enabling us to evaluate all dimensions of legal matters together with financial and technical matters.

The services that NAZALI provides to its clients include the most appropriate solution with the support of technical departments specialized in their fields. In this context, NAZALI associates are supported by NAZALI technical team and work alongside the experts in the fields of finance, social security and customs matters. NAZALI has set out with the aim of providing the most efficient and comprehensive solution for its clients by adapting to the developing conditions and happily gained the trust of its clients by never compromising the quality of service.

As conditions continuously evolve, NAZALI always aims to further itself remaining true to its motto “GROW WITH KNOWLEDGE” and has set out with the aim of providing the most efficient and comprehensive solution for its clients by adapting to the developing conditions and happily gained the trust of its clients by never compromising the quality of service.

Firm's website: http://www.nazali.com

Our Latest Issue