Fri, Jul
68 New Articles

Member State Authorities Cannot Withdraw Residence Permits Without Giving Reasons Even If the Reason is “TOP SECRET”

Member State Authorities Cannot Withdraw Residence Permits Without Giving Reasons Even If the Reason is “TOP SECRET”

  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

The Court of Justice of the European Union has decided in two cases concerning Hungary in its judgments in joined cases C-420/22 and C-528/22, published on 25 April 2024.

The underlying facts of the decision are as follows: two third-country nationals, one Turkish and one Nigerian, have been legally resident in Hungary for several years. One of them is the spouse of a woman of Hungarian nationality, with whom she is raising a child whose citizenship is Hungarian. The other person lives with his Hungarian partner and their two children, who are also Hungarian citizens. In 2020 and 2021, the Hungarian Constitution Protection Office issued two unsubstantiated statements stating that the presence of these third-country nationals in Hungary poses a threat to national security, however, the authority encrypted the data on which it relied on when adopting these resolutions. Consequently, the National Directorate-General for Aliens Policing was obliged to withdraw the permanent residence card of the first person and to order him to leave Hungary. It was also obliged to reject the application for a national permanent residence permit submitted by the second national referred to above. Neither the authority nor the persons concerned could have gained access to the confidential data on which the initial decisions were based.

The Szeged Regional Court, to which both persons had submitted an action against the decision of the National Directorate-General for Aliens Policing, referred questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on the compatibility of the Hungarian legislation with EU law.

The CJEU ruled that the Hungarian law is contrary to EU law if it requires national authorities to withdraw the residence permit of a family member of an EU citizen on grounds of national security, based on an unjustified opinion of a competent authority, or to refuse to issue a residence permit to the latter, without the latter having been able to carry out a thorough examination of the relevant individual circumstances and the proportionality of their decision.

Lastly, EU law precludes national legislation that prevents a family member of an EU citizen from whom a residence permit has been withdrawn or refused based on confidential data from being informed of the substance of the reasons on which those decisions are based and from using such data in administrative or judicial proceedings.

By Lilla Majoros, Attorney at law, KCG Partners Law Firm

Hungary Knowledge Partner

Nagy és Trócsányi was founded in 1991, turned into limited professional partnership (in Hungarian: ügyvédi iroda) in 1992, with the aim of offering sophisticated legal services. The firm continues to seek excellence in a comprehensive and modern practice, which spans international commercial and business law. 

The firm’s lawyers provide clients with advice and representation in an active, thoughtful and ethical manner, with a real understanding of clients‘ business needs and the markets in which they operate.

The firm is one of the largest home-grown independent law firms in Hungary. Currently Nagy és Trócsányi has 26 lawyers out of which there are 8 active partners. All partners are equity partners.

Nagy és Trócsányi is a legal entity and registered with the Budapest Bar Association. All lawyers of the Budapest office are either members of, or registered as clerks with, the Budapest Bar Association. Several of the firm’s lawyers are admitted attorneys or registered as legal consultants in New York.

The firm advises a broad range of clients, including numerous multinational corporations. 

Our activity focuses on the following practice areas: M&A, company law, litigation and dispute resolution, real estate law, banking and finance, project financing, insolvency and restructuring, venture capital investment, taxation, competition, utilities, energy, media and telecommunication.

Nagy és Trócsányi is the exclusive member firm in Hungary for Lex Mundi – the world’s leading network of independent law firms with in-depth experience in 100+countries worldwide.

The firm advises a broad range of clients, including numerous multinational corporations. Among our key clients are: OTP Bank, Sberbank, Erste Bank, Scania, KS ORKA, Mannvit, DAF Trucks, Booking.com, Museum of Fine Arts of Budapest, Hungarian Post Pte Ltd, Hiventures, Strabag, CPI Hungary, Givaudan, Marks & Spencer, CBA.

Firm's website.

Our Latest Issue