11
Sun, Apr
64 New Articles

Court of Justice Decides in Favour of Hungarian Taxpayers in Landmark Bad Debt Relief Case

Court of Justice Decides in Favour of Hungarian Taxpayers in Landmark Bad Debt Relief Case

Hungary
Tools
Typography
  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) established that for bad debt relief limitation period must begin to run not from the date of performance of the payment obligation initially provided for, but from the date on which the debt became definitively irrecoverable.

Recovery of VAT on bad debts has been on the agenda in Hungary since the Court of Justice of the European Union first clarified in the di Maura case at the end of 2017 and then in the Hungarian Porr case in 2019 that EU Member States need to provide for VAT recovery already paid on such claims. In several cases the Hungarian tax authority refused to refund the VAT on bad debts, since based on the general limitation period rule of 5 years, the limitation period from the original date of performance had expired.

In the current case - C‑507/20 – the Hungarian tax authority once again challenged the applicant taxpayer’s claim for reimbursement, since the limitation period expired since the original dates of performances in 2010 and 2011, respectively. The applicant, however, argued that debtor company was subject to winding up proceedings, and the liquidator recorded that the debt had become irrecoverable only in December 2019.  The applicant filed for reimbursement, in accordance with the Hungarian provisions on bad debt relief, once the irrevocability of the debt had been established officially.

Further to the request for preliminary ruling by the Hungarian Court, CJEU clearly established in its ruling of 3 March 2021 that the applicant has acted diligently and that it cannot be deprived of its right to a reduction of the taxable amount. It also follows that, in accordance with the existing case law in this regard, the limitation period for recovery of VAT on bad debts should only start from the date on which the debt became definitively irrecoverable.

This decision, alongside with a recent decision by the Supreme Court of Hungary on bad debt relief, should provide key precedent and clear interpretation in many similar cases where the Hungarian tax authority unlawfully limited the right of reduction and reimbursement of taxpayers regarding the previously duly paid VAT on bad debts.

By Balint Zsoldos, Head of Tax, KCG Partners Law Firm

Hungary Knowledge Partner

Nagy és Trócsányi was founded in 1991, turned into limited professional partnership (in Hungarian: ügyvédi iroda) in 1992, with the aim of offering sophisticated legal services. The firm continues to seek excellence in a comprehensive and modern practice, which spans international commercial and business law. 

The firm’s lawyers provide clients with advice and representation in an active, thoughtful and ethical manner, with a real understanding of clients‘ business needs and the markets in which they operate.

The firm is one of the largest home-grown independent law firms in Hungary. Currently Nagy és Trócsányi has 26 lawyers out of which there are 8 active partners. All partners are equity partners.

Nagy és Trócsányi is a legal entity and registered with the Budapest Bar Association. All lawyers of the Budapest office are either members of, or registered as clerks with, the Budapest Bar Association. Several of the firm’s lawyers are admitted attorneys or registered as legal consultants in New York.

The firm advises a broad range of clients, including numerous multinational corporations. 

Our activity focuses on the following practice areas: M&A, company law, litigation and dispute resolution, real estate law, banking and finance, project financing, insolvency and restructuring, venture capital investment, taxation, competition, utilities, energy, media and telecommunication.

Nagy és Trócsányi is the exclusive member firm in Hungary for Lex Mundi – the world’s leading network of independent law firms with in-depth experience in 100+countries worldwide.

The firm advises a broad range of clients, including numerous multinational corporations. Among our key clients are: OTP Bank, Sberbank, Erste Bank, Scania, KS ORKA, Mannvit, DAF Trucks, Booking.com, Museum of Fine Arts of Budapest, Hungarian Post Pte Ltd, Hiventures, Strabag, CPI Hungary, Givaudan, Marks & Spencer, CBA.

Firm's website.

Our Latest Issue