22
Sun, Sep
25 New Articles

Schmidt Law Office Obtains Preliminary Ruling Against Truck Cartel in European Court of Justice

Schmidt Law Office Obtains Preliminary Ruling Against Truck Cartel in European Court of Justice

Hungary
Typography

The Schmidt Law Office has successfully represented the interests of Hungary's Tibor Trans Ltd. before the European Court of Justice in its demand for damages resulting from a purported cartel of six truck manufacturers that operated to fix prices of medium and heavy trucks between January 1997 and January 2011.

According to the Schmidt Law Office, in its decision of July 29, 2019, "the European Court of Justice held [that] the place where the harmful event occurred is the place where the market prices were distorted and in which the victim claims to have suffered that damage. This means that claimants may bring their claims in their home countries’ courts, rather than the courts of the cartel members. Pending procedures may be continued throughout Europe – as the procedures suspended due to this preliminary ruling procedure.| 

According to the Schmidt Law Office, Tibor Trans would have bought its trucks at lower prices without the cartel, with the difference between those prices and what it was forced to pay constituting the damages it sought. The firm reports that "the lawsuit was initiated in Hungary against a Dutch producer which was not a contractual partner of Tibor Trans, but a participant of the cartel. The Hungarian court dismissed Tibor Trans’ claim based on lack of jurisdiction, [but] the second instance court turned to the European Court of Justice with a so=called preliminary ruling procedure – a procedure of interpretation if the contents of a legislative act are not clear."

According to the Schmidt Law Office, the ECJ's ruling that Tibor Trans – and other claimants – may initiate lawsuits in their home states as a place “where the damage occurred" is important, "because the default rule in international litigation is that the lawsuit takes place at the home state of the defendant."

Hungary Knowledge Partner

Established in 1957, Wolf Theiss is one of the leading European law firms in Central, Eastern and South-Eastern Europe with a focus on international business law. With 300 lawyers in 13 offices located in Albania, Austria, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia and Ukraine, Wolf Theiss represents local and international industrial, trade and service companies, as well as banks and insurance companies. Combining law and business, Wolf Theiss develops comprehensive and constructive solutions on the basis of legal, fiscal and business know-how.

All News about, and Legal Analysis by, Wolf Theiss can be found here.

Firm's website: http://www.wolftheiss.com/

Our Latest Issue