12
Tue, Dec
60 New Articles

Burden of Costs in Civil Litigation in Bulgaria

Burden of Costs in Civil Litigation in Bulgaria

Bulgaria
Typography

The burden of costs in litigation has always been of great importance to people and companies deciding whether to bring a civil action. 

Under Bulgaria’s current Civil Procedure Code (CPC), litigation costs include the state fee, lawyers’ fees, deposits for expert opinions appointed in the trial, fees for calling witnesses, and costs for obtaining interim measures. Litigation costs do not include the costs of translations, certifications, and legalization of documents, collection and examination of evidence, utilities, travel expenses, preliminary legal opinions, and so on. 

The basic principle in Bulgarian civil procedure law is that the losing party pays the litigation costs of the winning party, proportional to the accepted part of the claim. Each court instance is obliged to rule on the issue of costs in its judgment, and according to the established case law of the Supreme Court of Cassation of the Republic of Bulgaria (SCC), before the final hearing in each respective court instance each party must present the Court with a comprehensive list of its litigation costs – including lawyer’s fees – and evidence of actual payment. If a party fails to provide such a list, or fails to demonstrate actual payment, the Court will reject the claim for costs as unproven and the party will not have the right to seek an amendment of the judgment in this part.

The costs section is also an enforceable part of the court’s judgment. In order to pursue reimbursement of awarded costs, the party seeking them should obtain from the Court a writ of execution and initiate an enforcement case with a judicial enforcement officer (bailiff). Costs incurred within the enforcement case, such as bailiff’s fees and attorney’s fees, are also collectable from the debtor.

Unlike the state fees and the deposits for expert opinions and witnesses, which are both explicitly defined by law or by the Court, lawyer’s fees may be disputed as excessive by the opposite party. Objection may be filed until the last hearing in the respective court instance. The main criteria is whether the claimed fees correspond to the factual and legal complexity of the case. The Court, at its discretion, can decide to reduce the claimed lawyer’s fees as excessive. However, all Courts have to comply with the statutory case law of the SCC, according to which the lawyer’s remuneration cannot be reduced below the minimum amount stated in special Ordinance 1 of 2004 on the minimum amounts of attorney fees (promulgated in the Official Gazette by Issue 64/2004).

It is worth noting that the current CPC provides several exceptions to the basic principle on distribution of burden of litigation costs. The first exception depends on the outcome of the case, as each party has the right to claim its costs in accordance with the accepted or rejected part of the claim. The second exception depends on the behavior of the parties, as, if the defendant did not cause the litigation and acknowledges the claim, the costs are borne by the plaintiff, even though the decision is favorable to him. Another exception to the principle involves termination of the case due to refusal or withdrawal of the claim, procedural violations, non-payment of the state fee, inadmissibility of the claim, and so on, in which case the defendant’s costs should be borne by the plaintiff. In case of a court settlement, the parties may agree to split the costs. In such case, the Court reimburses 50 percent of the paid state fee to the plaintiff.

The Bulgarian CPC does not recognize the funding of litigation costs by outside third parties (which is allowed in the U.S., for example), but the parties have the option of purchasing litigation expenses insurance under the Bulgarian Insurance Code if the estimated cost amount is significant.

By Antonia Kehayova, Head of Dispute Resolution, CMS RRH Sofia

This Article was originally published in Issue 4.8 of the CEE Legal Matters Magazine. If you would like to receive a hard copy of the magazine, you can subscribe here.

Bulgaria Knowledge Partner

Schoenherr is a leading full-service law firm in Central and Eastern Europe. With 13 offices located in Belgrade, Bratislava, Brussels, Budapest, Bucharest, Chisinau, Istanbul, Ljubljana, Prague, Sofia, Vienna, Warsaw and Zagreb, as well as country desks for Albania, Bosnia-Herzegovina, Macedonia, Montenegro and Ukraine, Schoenherr provides its clients with comprehensive coverage of the CEE/SEE region. More than 300 legal professionals work across borders in both a centralized and de-centralized manner, according to the individual client’s needs and requirements. Quality, flexibility, innovation and practice-oriented solutions for complex assignments in the field of business law are at the core of the Schoenherr philosophy.

Firm's website can be found, here.

Our Latest Issue